Skip to content
Both Columns

Six different things share one name, and one of them is your own system

Buddy punching is misconduct. A refused punch is a fault. An extended break is usually the walk to the break room. Fifty notes on telling them apart, measuring what can be measured, and counting both directions.

All 50 notes

Set out as an account: the subject on the left, the notes on the right. The layout is a layout, not a chart — it says nothing about which column is larger. Working that out is what several of these notes are for.

The basics

3 notes

The term covers six things that need different responses. Separating them is most of the work.

Both directions

6 notes

The same records answer both questions. In most measured comparisons the unpaid column is larger, and it is the one with a statutory basis behind it.

Investigation

6 notes

Four system checks before anyone is spoken to, and the four tests that distinguish a real case from an anomaly.

Controls

5 notes

Each method addresses one failure and leaves the others open. Matching the method to the measured problem is the whole decision.

Legal

2 notes

Most of what decides these matters cannot be produced after the fact, and all of it is cheap to capture as habit.

Measuring

2 notes

Six measurements, each an afternoon, that between them replace every industry statistic in this subject.

What not to do

3 notes

The asks that arrive once someone has decided there is a problem, and what to offer instead of each.

Reference

5 notes

The end state as a checklist, the questions the data cannot answer, and where to start depending on your situation.

What this is

Fifty notes on the category called time theft, written for whoever has been asked to do something about it.

No vendor material, no product names, no sponsored content, and no industry percentages.

Four things that hold

Six different things share the name. One is misconduct, one is your own system failing, and one cannot be measured without surveillance that would be disproportionate. They need different responses.

A large share of what gets counted is a fault. A refused punch, a forgotten clock-out, a queue at shift change — none of these is a decision by anyone, and all of them land in the same column.

The ledger runs both ways. Pre-shift minutes, handover, rounding drift and deducted breaks are measurable from the same records, and in most operations that have counted both, the second figure is larger.

The technical controls come fourth, behind slack in the rules, fixing the structural causes, and supervision — all of which cost nothing.

Where to start

A purchase has been proposed: what the term covers, then working out how much you have.

A specific case is live: running an investigation, and the four checks it opens with.

The records are producing complaints: when the system is the problem.

You want the number that changes the conversation: the other direction.

What this is not

Not legal advice. References to working time, deductions, monitoring and disciplinary procedure are general and vary substantially by jurisdiction.

It does not describe how to configure screen capture or keystroke counting, how to monitor covertly, or how to present an automatic trigger as a human decision. Those appear only in the notes about why they should not be done.

Independent software comparisons

Long-form shortlists for attendance, remote time records and workforce management.

For one live product reference, visit the official website and apply the same identity, export and reconciliation tests described throughout these notes.